E-ISSN:2349-4166
P-ISSN:2349-4158

Research Article

Psychiatric

Public Health Review - International Journal of Public Health Research

2017 Volume 4 Number 2 March-April
Publisherwww.medresearch.in

Psychiatric morbidity in parents of children with behavioral problems attending child guidance clinic

C Babu T.1, Saji K.2, Raj Eliza S.3*
DOI: https://doi.org/10.17511/ijphr.2017.i2.03

1 Tom C Babu, Assistant Surgeon, Department of Psychiatry, Taluk Hospital, Chettikad, Kerala, India.

2 Saji K, Additional Professor, Department of Psychiatry, Government T D Medical College, Alappuzha, Kerala, India.

3* Sharon Raj Eliza, Post Graduate student, Department of Community Medicine, Government TD Medical College, Alappuzha, Kerala, India.

Introduction: Psychiatric morbidity in parents can influence behavioral problems in children and behavioral problems in child can cause heightened family distress. Our objectives were to evaluate the frequency and nature of psychiatric morbidities in parents of children with psychiatric illness and to study their association. Methodology: The study sample included parents of children with behavioral problems attending the child guidance clinic, Government Medical College, Kottayam, Kerala. Children were initially screened using Childhood Psychopathology Measurement Schedule and in those screened positive the diagnosis was confirmed using the DCR criteria for ICD -10. The parents of those children were screened using the General Health Questionnaire-12 and those who scored above cut off were evaluated for psychiatric disorders by taking history doing detailed physical examination and mental status examination. Statistical analysis was done to find the frequency and nature of illnesses and the association between parental and child diagnoses. Results: 61% of the fathers and 25% of the mothers had psychiatric morbidity. Significant associations were found between 1) conduct disorders in children with fathers’ alcohol dependence and bipolar affective disorder and mothers’ depressive disorder 2) ADHD (F90.0) in children with fathers’ alcohol harmful use 3) Hyperkinetic conduct disorder(ADHD+CD) in children with fathers’ alcohol dependence and bipolar affective disorder and mothers’ depression 4) Pervasive developmental disorder in children with fathers’ alcohol dependence 5) Mental retardation in children with fathers’ alcohol dependence. Conclusion: Parents of children with behavioural problems have higher rate of psychiatric morbidity and there are significant associations between many conditions in parents and their children.

Keywords: Parental psychiatric morbidity, ADHD/hyperkinetic disorders, Conduct disorders

Corresponding Author How to Cite this Article To Browse
Sharon Raj Eliza, Post Graduate student, Department of Community Medicine, Government TD Medical College, Alappuzha, Kerala, India.
Email:
Babu TC, Saji K, Eliza SR. Psychiatric morbidity in parents of children with behavioral problems attending child guidance clinic. Public Health Rev Int J Public Health Res. 2017;4(2):45-52.
Available From
https://publichealth.medresearch.in/index.php/ijphr/article/view/61

Manuscript Received Review Round 1 Review Round 2 Review Round 3 Accepted
2017-04-04 2017-04-13 2017-04-22 2017-04-30
Conflict of Interest Funding Ethical Approval Plagiarism X-checker Note
No Nil Yes 5%

© 2017 by Tom C Babu, Saji K, Sharon Raj Eliza and Published by Siddharth Health Research and Social Welfare Society. This is an Open Access article licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ unported [CC BY 4.0].

Introduction

According to World Health Organisation (WHO) statistics, prevalence of disabling mental illnesses among children and adolescents attending urban health centers ranges between 20-30% and 13-18% in rural areas. Out of these 3-4% are suffering from serious mental illnesses and require treatment [1]. Millions of children and adolescents are exposed to parental mental health problems at any given time [2].

Studies have noted that offspring of mentally ill parents have higher rates of psychiatric diagnoses in childhood and are more likely to show developmental delays, lower academic competence, and difficulty with social relationships [3]. In addition, these offspring are more likely to have mental health problems in adolescence and adulthood [4]. Childhood is the developmental period in which most children are not only living with parents, but are also almost completely dependent on parents for their emotional and physical needs.

Objectives

  1. To evaluate the frequency and nature of psychiatric morbidities in parents of children attending the child guidance clinic.
  2. To study the association between the psychiatric morbidity in children with their parental psychiatric morbidity.

Methodology

Study design: Cross-sectional study.

Study period: 1/7/2014 to 30/6/2015

Study setting: Child Guidance Clinic (CGC), Department of Psychiatry, Government Medical College, Kottayam, Kerala.

Inclusion criteria for children

  1. Children with a definite diagnosis of psychiatric illness as per the diagnostic criteria for research (DCR-10).
  2. Children with age less than 12 years.
  3. Children of parents giving consent

Exclusion criteria for children

  1. Adopted children
  2. Children who are physically unfit for evaluation.
  3. Parents inaccessible.

Inclusion criteria for parents

  1. Biological parents.
  2. Parents living with the child.

Exclusion criteria for parents

  1. Parents with severe debilitating physical illnesses.

Study tools

  1. Diagnostic Criteria for research (DCR-10)[5]
  2. Childhood Psychopathology Measurement Schedule[6]
  3. The General Health Questionnaire – 12 Version (David Goldberg,[7]
  4. Kuppuswamy’s Socioeconomic Status Scale

A specially designed pro-forma is used for collecting relevant socio demographic and psychiatric details.

The study sample includes parents of children with behavioral problems attending the child guidance clinic (CGC), Government Medical College, Kottayam for the first time, who has satisfied the inclusion and exclusion criteria.

The subjects were explained about the purpose of the study and were included in the study after getting an informed consent. Each child was initially screened using Childhood Psychopathology Measurement Schedule and in those screened positive the diagnosis was confirmed using the DCR criteria for ICD -10.

The parents of those children with a definite psychiatric illness was initially screened using the General Health Questionnaire-12 and those who are getting a score of 3 and above was further evaluated for psychiatric disorders by taking history, doing detailed physical examination and mental status examination and the diagnosis was confirmed using DCR criteria for ICD-10.

The data was collected and tabulated. Statistical analysis was done using the computer software, Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS) 16.0.

Results

The study included parents of 200 children from child guidance clinic. The mean age of the children was 8.32 with standard deviation (SD) 1.997. Mean age of father was 37.37 and mean age of mother was 33.09. Out of the total children included in the study 75.5% of them were males 24.5% were females.


Among the 200 fathers 122 had psychiatric morbidity of which most common was harmful use of alcohol in 60 fathers (30%) followed by alcohol dependence syndrome in 38 fathers (19%). 8 fathers had co morbid psychiatric disorder along with alcohol use disorder of which mood disorder was commonest. Out of the 200 mothers 50 (25%) had psychiatric morbidity of which depressive disorders n=22(11%) was the most common followed by anxiety disorder n=18 (9%).

Significant associations were found between 1) conduct disorders in children with fathers’ alcohol dependence and bipolar affective disorder and mothers’ depressive disorder 2) ADHD (F90.0) in children with fathers’ alcohol harmful use 3)Hyperkinetic conduct disorder(ADHD+CD) in children with fathers’ alcohol dependence and bipolar affective disorder and mothers’ depression 4) Pervasive developmental disorder in children with fathers’ alcohol dependence 5) Mental retardation in children with fathers’ alcohol dependence and psychosis .

Table-1: showing various psychiatric diagnosis of children attending child guidance clinic

Diagnosis Number of children Percentage
Hyperkinetic disorder(F90.0/ADHD) 22 11%
Specific learning disorder(F81/SLD) 16 8%
Conduct disorders(F91/CDs) 11 5.5%
Mental retardation(MR) 24 12%
Pervasive developmental Disorders(F84/PDDs) 14 7%
Bipolar affective disorder(F31/BPAD) 5 2.5%
Depressive disorders(F32/f33) 3 1.5%
Anxiety disorders 15 7.5%
ADHD+SLD(F90.0+F81) 47 23.5%
Hyperkinetic conduct disorder(F90.1/ADHD+CD) 27 13.5%
SLD+CD 6 3%
SLD+ anxiety disorder 2 1%
SLD+ others* 1 0.5%
CD+ others* 1 0.5%
MR+ anxiety 1 0.5%
Others* 5 2.5%
Total 200 100%

*Others included 2 children with non-organic sleep disorders, 3 children with post encephalitic sequelae and 2 children with non-organic enuresis

Table-2: Psychiatric morbidity among fathers of children attending child guidance clinic

Psychiatric morbidity Number Percentage
Alcohol dependence syndrome(ADS) 38 19%
Alcohol harmful use 60 30%
Psychotic disorders(F20-F29) 2 1%
Bipolar affective disorders(F31/BPAD) 7 3.5%
Depressive disorders(F32/F33) 1 0.5%
Anxiety disorders(F40-F48) 6 3%
Ads +anxiety disorder 3 1.5%
Alcohol harmful use + anxiety disorder 2 1%
BPAD +ADS 3 1.5%
No disorder 78 39%
Total 200 100%

Table-3: Psychiatric morbidity in mothers attending child guidance clinic

Psychiatric morbidity Number Percentage
Bipolar affective disorder(F31/BPAD) 4 2%
Depressive disorders(F32/F33) 22 11%
Anxiety disorders(F40-F48) 18 9%
Depression +anxiety disorders 5 2.5%
Mental retardation 1 0.5%
No disorders 150 75%
Total 200 100%

Table-4: Association between paternal psychiatric illness and child ADHD

Child diagnosis Paternal diagnosis P value Chi square value
ADHD Alcohol dependence 0.085 2.972
  Depression* 1.000 0.124
  Anxiety* 1.000 0.043
  Psychosis* 1.000 0.250
  BPAD* 0.606 1.301
  Alcohol harmful use 0.041 4.172
ADHD with conduct disorder Alcohol dependence 0.011 6.389
  Depression* 1.000 0.157
  Anxiety* 0.366 1.817
  Psychosis* 1.000 0.315
  BPAD*  0.005 12.009
  Alcohol harmful use 0.104 2.630
ADHD with  specific learning disorder Alcohol dependence 0.790 0.071
  Depression* 1.000 0.309
  Anxiety* 0.464 1.344
  Psychosis* 0.416 0.789
  BPAD* 1.000 0.072
  Alcohol harmful use 0.606 0.266

The criteria for diagnosing disorders were according to the Diagnostic Criteria for Research (DCR 10) accompanying the ICD 10. But some of the names of the diagnoses have been used interchangeably with DSM-5 since most of the studies on childhood disorders were based on DSM.

Table-5: Association between paternal and child psychiatric illness (except ADHD)

Child diagnosis Paternal diagnosis P value Chi square value
Conduct disorders Alcohol dependence* 0.000 20.334
  Depression* 1.000 0.267
  Anxiety* 0.125 3.094
  Psychosis* 1.000 0.537
  BPAD* 0.007 9.651
  Alcohol harmful use 0.713 0.135
PDD Alcohol dependence* 0.025 4.0903
  Depression* 1.000 0.087
  Anxiety* 1.000 0.019
  Psychosis* 1.000 0.176
  BPAD* 1.000 0.915
  Alcohol harmful use 0.982 0.001
MR Alcohol dependence* 0.007 6.803
  Depression* 1.000 0.170
  Anxiety* 0.372 1.974
  Psychosis* 0.020 11.912
  BPAD* 1.000 0.172
  Alcohol  harmful use 0.083 3.002
SLD Alcohol dependence 0.850 0.036
  Depression* 0.330 2.041
  Anxiety* 0.345 1.156
  Psychosis* 1.000 0.995
  BPAD* 0.170 2.519
  Alcohol harmful use 0.424 0.640
BPAD Alcohol dependence* 1.000 0.012
  Depression* 1.000 0.026
  Anxiety* 0.246 2.074
  Psychosis* 1.000 0.052
  BPAD* 0.228 2.420
  Alcohol  harmful use 1.000 0.290
Depression Alcohol dependence* 1.000 0.859
  Depression* 1.000 0.015
  Anxiety* 0.157 2.540
  Psychosis* 1.000 0.031
  BPAD* 1.000 0.160
  Alcohol harmful use* 1.000 0.008

Table-6: Association between maternal and child psychiatric illness (except ADHD)

Child diagnosis Maternal diagnosis P value Chi square value
Conduct disorder Psychosis* 1.000 0.537
Bipolar* 0.062 2.224
  Depression 0.028 4.837
Anxiety 0.524 0.405
Intellectual disability* 0.210 3.781
Id Psychosis* 0.270 2.054
Bipolar* 1.000 0.027
Depression* 1.000 0.002
Anxiety 0.093 2.814
Intellectual disability* 1.000 0.170
Pdd Psychosis* 1.000 0.176
Bipolar* 1.000 0.725
Depression* 1.000 0.015
Anxiety* 0.700 0.471
Intellectual disability* 1.000 0.087
Specific learning disorder Psychosis* 0.552 0.264
BPAD* 1.000 0.241
Depression* 0.511 0.706
Anxiety 0.222 1.491
Intellectual disability* 1.000 0.495
Bipolar affective disorder(BPAD) Psychosis* 1.000 0.052
BPAD* 1.000 0.214
Depression* 0.520 0.186
Anxiety* 0.461 0.364
Intellectual disability* 1.000 0.026
Depression Psychosis* 1.000 0.031
BPAD* 0.116 2.825
Depression* 0.354 1.026
Anxiety* 1.000 0.396
Intellectual disability* 1.000 0.015
Anxiety Psychosis* 1.000 0.176
BPAD* 0.493 0.229
Depression* 1.000 0.015
Anxiety* 0.404 0.898
Intellectual disability* 1.000 0.087

Table-7: Association between maternal psychiatric illness and child ADHD

ADHD Psychosis* 1.000 0.250
BPAD* 0.602 1.030
Depression* 0.745 0.412
Anxiety* 0.479 1.175
Intellectual disability* 1.000 1.24
ADHD with conduct disorder Psychosis* 1.000 0.315
BPAD* 0.077 4.110
Depression* 0.008 6.954
Anxiety* 0.524 0.337
Intellectual disability* 1.000 0.156
ADHD with SLD Psychosis* 0.416 0.789
BPAD* 1.000 0.010
Depression* 0.630 0.431
Anxiety 0.756 0.097
Intellectual disability* 1.000 0.309

Test used was Pearson chi square test, df =1, p value significant level <0.05(*fischer’s exact test value).

Discussion

In our study total of 122 fathers and 50 mothers had psychiatric morbidity which constitute 43 % of parents of either sex. This is in correspondence with the study done in Philipps University Marburg Germany which showed 48.3 % of parents of either sex had psychiatric morbidity [8]. Most common psychiatric morbidity among fathers was harmful use of alcohol(30%) followed by alcohol dependence syndrome in 38 fathers (19%). This is in accordance with the study by Philipps University Marburg Germany which showed 20.7 % of substance dependence among parents of children with psychiatric disorders.Among the mothers depressive disorder n=22(11%) was the most common psychiatric morbidity followed by anxiety disorder n=18 (9%) [8]. As per a study from a south Indian rural population prevalence of depressive disorder was 14.82% and anxiety was 4% [9]. Significant association was found between, ADHD in children with fathers’ alcohol harmful use (p=0.041).A study done in US found that there is significant association between ADHD in children and fathers’ substance use disorder. In this study 29% of children with ADHD had their fathers having substance use disorder [10]. In this study there was significant association between ADHD with conduct disorder (CD) in children and fathers’ alcohol dependence (p= 0.011) and bipolar affective disorder (p=0.005) and mothers’ depression (p=0.008). The US study also found similar association with 31.5% of children with ADHD and conduct disorder had their fathers having substance use disorder and 43.3% of mothers having mood disorder [10]. Mental retardation in children was significantly associated with fathers’ alcohol dependence (p=0.007) and psychosis (p=0.020).An Indian study on parents of children with mental retardation found significant association between mental retardation in children and dysthymia ,anxiety disorder and depression in parents.Substance use disorder is highly co-morbid with all these conditions [11].

Conclusion

Psychiatric illnesses in parents represent a risk for children in the family. These children have a higher risk for developing behavioral problems than other children.

Medical, mental health or social service professionals working with mentally ill adults need to inquire about the children and adolescents, especially about their mental health and emotional development.

Reference

  1. WHO. The World Health Report 2000- Health Systems- Improving performance. Geneva-World Health Organization. 2000.
  2. Creswell C, Brereton J. Community mental health services and the children of service users. Clinical Psychology Forum. 2000;144;4-6.
  3. Oyserman D, Mowbray CT, Meares PA, Firminger KB. Parenting among mothers with a serious mental illness. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry. 2000;70(3)296-315.
  4. Weissman, Myrna M. Offspring of depressed parents- 10 years later. Archives of General Psychiatry. 1997;54(10)932.
  5. WHO. ICD 10- International Classification of Diseases, Diagnostic Criteria for Research. Geneva- World health Organisation. 2003.
  6. Savita Malhotra, V K Varma et al. Childhood psychopathology measurement schedule development and standardization. Indian J Psychiatry. 1988;30(4)325–31.
  7. Goldberg DP, Gater R, et al. The Validity Of Two Versions Of The GHQ In The Who Study Of Mental Illness In General Health Care. Psychological Medicine. 1997;27(1)191-7.
  8. Jacob CP, Romanos J. Co-morbidity of adult attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder with focus on personality traits and related disorders in a tertiary referral center. European Archives of Psychiatry and Clinical Neurosciences. 2007;257(6)309–317.

  1. Rao TSS, Darsan MS, et al. Suttur study- An epidemiological study of psychiatric disorders in south Indian rural population. Indian Journal of Psychiatry. 2014;56(3)238-245.
  2. Chronis AM, Lahey BB, Pelham WE, Kipp HL, Baumann BL, Lee SS. Psychopathology & substance abuse in parents of young children with attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Pychiatry. 2003;42(12)1424-32.
  3. Chandorkar H, Chakraborty PK. Psychological Morbidity Of Parents Of Mentally Retarded Children. Indian Journal of Psychiatry. 2000;42(3)271-274, PMCID: PMC2958351.